Access Denied: Solving 403 Forbidden Errors in Amazon S3

Question:

Asked by Jurgen:

"I’ve set up an S3 bucket and added a bucket policy to allow public access. However, when users try to access objects in the bucket, they get a 403 Forbidden error. The bucket policy seems correct. What might be causing this issue, and how can I resolve it?"

Greeting:

Hi Jurgen,

Thanks for sharing this common and frustrating challenge! S3’s security model is robust but can feel like a puzzle when you encounter access issues. Let’s unpack why users might be seeing a 403 Forbidden error despite having a bucket policy that looks correct and how to fix it. 🚀

Clarifying the Issue:

Based on your description, it sounds like you’re encountering access errors caused by conflicting or incomplete permissions in your bucket setup. This could involve issues with the bucket policy, IAM role permissions, or even the bucket's public access settings.

Why This Matters:

403 Forbidden errors can halt productivity, frustrate users, and disrupt workflows, especially if your bucket is hosting a public resource or application assets. By systematically addressing these issues, you can ensure your S3 resources remain accessible without compromising security.

Key Terms:

• Bucket Policy: A JSON document defining access permissions at the bucket level.
• IAM Policy: Permissions applied to users, groups, or roles interacting with S3.
• Block Public Access Settings: Account- or bucket-level settings that override public permissions.
• 403 Forbidden Error: An HTTP response indicating access denial.

Steps at a Glance:

1. Check and adjust S3 bucket policies.
2. Verify IAM role or user policies.
3. Use the AWS S3 Console Debugger.
4. If you have CloudWatch enabled, analyze logs for access errors.
5. If you have CloudTrail enabled, audit logs for request details.
6. Confirm object-level permissions.
7. Review the overall permission flow to identify conflicts.
8. Test with AWS CLI or browser access, including role-based testing.

Step-by-Step Guide:

1. Check and Adjust S3 Bucket Policies

   • Ensure the bucket policy grants s3:GetObject permissions to the Principal (e.g., * for public access).

   • Example bucket policy for public read access:

     JSON

     {
         "Version": "2012-10-17",
         "Statement": [
             {
                 "Effect": "Allow",
                 "Principal": "*",
                 "Action": "s3:GetObject",
                 "Resource": "arn:aws:s3:::your-bucket-name/*"
             }
         ]
     }
     

   • Confirm that the Resource ARN is correctly specified for the bucket and objects.

2. Verify IAM Role or User Policies

   • Ensure the IAM entity interacting with the bucket has the necessary permissions (s3:GetObject).

   • Example IAM policy:

     JSON

     {
         "Version": "2012-10-17",
         "Statement": [
             {
                 "Effect": "Allow",
                 "Action": "s3:GetObject",
                 "Resource": "arn:aws:s3:::your-bucket-name/*"
             }
         ]
     }
     

   • Verify that no Deny statements conflict with the permissions granted in this policy.

3. Use the AWS S3 Console Debugger

   • Navigate to the Permissions tab in the S3 Console.
   • Use the built-in debugger to analyze:
     • Bucket policies
     • Access control lists (ACLs)
   • The debugger can help pinpoint misconfigurations, such as conflicting permissions or missing s3:GetObject actions.

4. If You Have CloudWatch Enabled

   • Use CloudWatch Logs Insights to troubleshoot access issues and identify patterns in requests:
     • Example query to find 403 Access Denied errors:

       fields @timestamp, @message
       | filter @message like /403/
       | sort @timestamp desc
       | limit 20
       

   • If CloudWatch is not yet enabled:
     • Enable logging for S3 via the Bucket Settings tab in the S3 Console for future analysis.

5. If You Have CloudTrail Enabled

   • Use CloudTrail logs to audit requests made to your S3 bucket:
     • Look for entries with the Error Code 403 Access Denied.
     • Analyze request details such as:
       • Source IP address
       • User agent
       • IAM role/user making the request
   • If CloudTrail is not yet enabled:
     • Enable it via the CloudTrail Console for tracking future activity.

6. Confirm Object-Level Permissions

   • Even if the bucket policy allows access, object-level ACLs may restrict it.
   • Grant public read permissions for objects via the AWS S3 Console or CLI:
     • Example CLI command:
       Bash

       aws s3api put-object-acl --bucket your-bucket-name --key your-object-key --acl public-read
       

7. Review the Overall Permission Flow

   Misconfigurations often arise due to conflicts across different permission layers. Use this flow to identify where the denial occurs:

   • IAM Policy → Grants or denies access at the account or user/role level.
   • Bucket Policy → Specifies access rules for the entire bucket.
   • Object ACL → Determines permissions for individual objects.
   • Block Public Access → Overrides all public permissions if enabled.

   If any layer denies access, the request results in a 403 Forbidden error.

8. Test with AWS CLI or Browser Access, Including Role-Based Testing

   • Use the AWS CLI to confirm access:

     Bash

     aws s3 ls s3://your-bucket-name
     

   • Test with a browser by accessing the object’s public URL:

     https://your-bucket-name.s3.amazonaws.com/your-object-key

   • Perform role-based testing:

     • Test access with different IAM roles or user accounts that interact with the bucket.
     • This ensures all relevant users have appropriate permissions without conflicts.

Closing Thoughts

403 errors are often a result of layered permissions in S3’s security model. By systematically reviewing your bucket policy, IAM permissions, public access settings, and object ACLs, you can resolve these errors efficiently. Leveraging AWS tools like CloudWatch and CloudTrail provides valuable insights for troubleshooting and ensures robust, long-term access control.

Farewell:

I hope this guide helps you resolve your S3 403 Forbidden issues, Jurgen! If you have more questions or need additional assistance, feel free to ask. Best of luck, and happy building! 😊

Need AWS Expertise?

If you're looking for guidance on AWS challenges or want to collaborate, feel free to reach out! We'd love to help you tackle your cloud projects. 🚀

Email us at: info@pacificw.com

Image: Gerd Altmann from Pixabay