Why Is My S3 Bucket Policy Blocking Access Even Though It Looks Correct?

Why Is My S3 Bucket Policy Blocking Access Even Though It Looks Correct?

Question

"Why am I getting these blasted Access Denied or 403 Forbidden errors when I try to upload, download, or list objects in my S3 bucket? I’m certain my bucket policy is perfect—what’s going on?" – Jurgen, an S3 enthusiast who doesn’t like surprises.

Greeting

Hello, AWS troubleshooters! If you’ve ever found yourself channeling your inner Jurgen, wondering why S3 refuses to cooperate, you’re not alone. Let’s break it all down step-by-step and uncover the truth behind these pesky access errors.

Clarifying the Issue

S3 permissions operate on multiple layers, which can lead to conflicts even when one layer (like your bucket policy) seems correct. Common access denied scenarios include:

• "Access Denied": Indicates missing permissions at any level, from IAM to ACLs.
• "403 Forbidden": Suggests that the requester is authenticated but doesn’t have sufficient permissions for the requested action.

These errors often stem from conflicts among S3 bucket policies, IAM permissions, object ACLs, or organizational SCPs.

Why This Matters

Access issues can cause application disruptions, delayed workflows, and even introduce security risks. Understanding how AWS evaluates permissions ensures you can resolve these problems confidently and securely.

Steps at a Glance

1. Verify Public Access Blocker Settings
2. Check for Explicit Denies in IAM Policies
3. Test Access with IAM Access Analyzer
4. Inspect Object ACLs
5. Review Service Control Policies (SCPs)
6. Test Permissions Using AWS CLI
7. Review the Overall Permission Flow

Detailed Steps

1. Verify Public Access Blocker Settings

• Navigate to the S3 console, select your bucket, and check the Public Access Blocker settings under Permissions.
• Ensure the settings match your intended use case. For example, if your bucket requires public read access, disable Block Public Access for that specific bucket.

Example Policy for Public Read Access:

JSON

{
  "Version": "2012-10-17",
  "Statement": [
    {
      "Effect": "Allow",
      "Principal": "*",
      "Action": "s3:GetObject",
      "Resource": "arn:aws:s3:::example-bucket/*"
    }
  ]
}

2. Check for Explicit Denies in IAM Policies

• Open the IAM console and review policies attached to the affected user, group, or role.
• Look for Deny statements targeting S3 actions. Remember, explicit denies override all allow permissions.

Example Policy with Deny Statement:

JSON

{
  "Version": "2012-10-17",
  "Statement": [
    {
      "Effect": "Deny",
      "Action": "s3:*",
      "Resource": "arn:aws:s3:::example-bucket/*"
    }
  ]
}

If such a policy exists, modify it to target only the actions you want to restrict or remove it altogether.

3. Test Access with IAM Access Analyzer

• Use IAM Access Analyzer to simulate access requests and identify conflicts.

Steps:

• Navigate to Access Analyzer in the IAM console.
• Create a simulation query for the specific action (e.g., s3:GetObject).
• Review the simulation results to pinpoint the conflicting policy or setting.

4. Inspect Object ACLs

• Check object ACLs to ensure individual permissions aren’t blocking access.
• Navigate to the S3 console, select the object, and review its ACL under Permissions.

Example ACL Granting Public Read Access:

JSON

{
  "Owner": {
    "DisplayName": "bucket-owner",
    "ID": "bucket-owner-id"
  },
  "Grants": [
    {
      "Grantee": {
        "Type": "Group",
        "URI": "http://acs.amazonaws.com/groups/global/AllUsers"
      },
      "Permission": "READ"
    }
  ]
}

5. Review Service Control Policies (SCPs)

• If your account is part of an AWS Organization, SCPs might restrict the required action.
• Go to the AWS Organizations console and check SCPs applied at the account or organizational level.

Example SCP Restricting Deletion Actions:

JSON

{
  "Version": "2012-10-17",
  "Statement": [
    {
      "Effect": "Deny",
      "Action": "s3:DeleteObject",
      "Resource": "*"
    }
  ]
}

6. Test Permissions Using AWS CLI

• Use the AWS CLI to test access interactively.

Example Command:

To upload a file and verify permissions:

Bash

aws s3 cp testfile.txt s3://example-bucket/ --region us-east-1

If access is denied, the error message will help you identify which permission layer is causing the issue.

7. Review the Overall Permission Flow

After working through the practical troubleshooting steps, it’s helpful to reflect on how AWS evaluates permissions. Misconfigurations often arise due to conflicts across different layers. Use this flow to identify where access might be denied:

• IAM Policy → Grants or denies access at the account or user/role level.
• Bucket Policy → Specifies access rules for the entire bucket.
• Object ACL → Determines permissions for individual objects.
• Block Public Access → Overrides all public permissions if enabled.

If any layer denies access, the request results in a 403 Forbidden error. Reflecting on this flow can help you better understand the root causes of access issues and apply these insights in future troubleshooting. 😊

Closing Thoughts

Jurgen might be frustrated, but by peeling back the layers of AWS permissions, you’ll find the source of any access issue. Explicit denies, public access blockers, and conflicting ACLs are common culprits—but each has a clear path to resolution. Follow these steps, and you’ll not only resolve your issue but also gain a better understanding of AWS’s security model.

Farewell

That’s it for today, friends! May your S3 buckets stay accessible and your permissions flawless. Until next time, keep building and troubleshooting like a pro—Jurgen would be proud! 😊🚀

Need AWS Expertise?

If you're looking for guidance on AWS challenges or want to collaborate, feel free to reach out! We'd love to help you tackle your cloud projects. 🚀

Email us at: info@pacificw.com

Image: TyliJura from Pixabay