Insight: Why You Can’t INSERT into Shared Redshift Tables—And What to Do Instead

Insight: Why You Can’t INSERT into Shared Redshift Tables—And What to Do Instead

Data sharing in Amazon Redshift makes it easy to expose tables from one cluster (or namespace) to another—often across teams, accounts, or organizations. But when you try to go beyond simple reads, you may run into an unexpected wall:

bash

Operation not supported on external tables.

This error typically appears when you attempt to INSERT, UPDATE, or DELETE on a Redshift table that’s been shared with your cluster. It can feel confusing at first: everything else works. You can query the data, join it, filter it—so why not write to it?

Read-Only by Design

This is not a permissions issue, nor a resource constraint. It’s simply how Redshift data sharing is built.

When data is shared between clusters, the receiving (consumer) cluster sees those tables through an external schema. These look native, but they remain fully owned and governed by the producer. That’s why they’re read-only by design—no direct modifications allowed from the outside.

AWS enforces this boundary to preserve data integrity and prevent accidental changes across environments. Even when data is shared between two workgroups in the same AWS account, the consumer cluster has no write privileges on those external tables.

Confirm It for Yourself

If you’re unsure whether a table belongs to a shared external schema, this quick diagnostic query will tell you: 

sql

-- Confirm if table is part of an external (shared) schema
select table_schema, table_name, is_insertable_into
from information_schema.tables
where table_schema = 'your_external_schema';

If is_insertable_into returns NO, that’s your confirmation. The table is read-only, and no amount of permission changes or cluster resizing will enable writes.

This applies across all Redshift deployment types—provisioned or serverless, namespace or workgroup. The behavior is consistent and intentional.

What Comes Next

If you absolutely need to insert data that originated from your consumer cluster, you’ll need to do it through a different pathway. Whether that’s a staging pipeline, an API-based write endpoint, or a shared S3 data lake—we’ll walk through those architectural patterns in our follow-up post.

For now, don’t waste time chasing a workaround where none exists. Instead, treat this as a known boundary—and a signal to reconsider how your workflow moves data.

* * * 

Written by Aaron Rose, software engineer and technology writer at Tech-Reader.blog.